ARTICLE

Participating Insurance: Fulfilment Ratio & Total Cash Value Ratio Guide

 

18-min read

Updated on 2026-9-25

Author: AIA Content Editorial Team

A young smiling Asian woman managing her finance with smartphone in the living room at home.
Whether you are preparing for retirement savings or an education fund for your children, a participating insurance is one of the tools in the market that is considered to have wealth accumulation potential when carrying out long-term financial planning.
 
Participating insurances are commonly found in long-term insurance products, including whole life insurance, savings insurance plans, or critical illness insurance products with savings components. The bonuses (or dividends) under participating insurance s are non-guaranteed benefits. You may refer to the Fulfilment Ratio to understand whether an insurer's participating insurances have achieved their non-guaranteed benefits over a certain period in the past.
 
You may also refer to the Total Cash Value Ratio to understand the overall performance of the guaranteed and non-guaranteed benefits of participating insurances in the past. Please note that the Fulfilment Ratio and Total Cash Value Ratio only reflect past performance and do not represent future performance. Please be alerted that historical dividends / bonuses are not an indicator of future dividends / bonuses declaration of participating products.
Before purchasing an insurance product, customers must complete a financial needs analysis and assess the product based on their personal financial goals, protection needs, affordability, risk tolerance and product suitability.

What Is a Participating Insurance? Understanding Its Basic Operating Principles

Participating insurances are common long-term insurance products in the market1, such as life insurance plans with savings components. The core concept is to allow policyholders to share a portion of the profits earned on it and related participating insurance plans with the policy owners. These products are designed to provide both life protection and long-term savings benefits. 

What Is the Difference Between Guaranteed Benefits and Non-Guaranteed Benefits?

In the benefit illustration of a participating insurance, the benefits are generally divided into two main categories2: 
 
  • Guaranteed Benefits:

    Guaranteed benefits refer to the amounts stated in the policy terms and conditions that the insurance company is obligated to pay. Regardless of changes in market conditions, the insurer must pay the specified amount according to the policy terms.

  • Non-Guaranteed Benefits:

    Non-guaranteed benefits refer to the portion of returns that may vary depending on different factors. The final amount payable may be affected by factors including the insurer's investment strategy and actual performance, claims experience, operating expenses and other relevant factors.

Key Differences Between Participating and Non-Participating Insurances

Before purchasing an insurance policy, it is important to understand the key differences between participating and non-participating insurances:
Comparison ItemParticipating InsuranceNon-Participating Insurance
Premium Level (for the same sum assured)Generally relatively higher.Generally relatively lower.
Return PotentialIn general, a higher proportion of non-guaranteed benefits may indicate higher potential returns. However, the benefits received by policyholders may also be subject to greater fluctuations, and the uncertainty of non-guaranteed benefits may be relatively higher.Generally provides fixed amounts stated in the policy, without additional returns.
Return StabilityMay be affected by factors including the insurer's investment performance, claims experience and operating expenses, and therefore involves relatively higher fluctuation risks.Relatively stable and not affected by market fluctuations.
If you would like to explore more solutions that cater to different life stages, you can learn more about life insurance products.

What Is Policy Cash Value?

Policy cash value refers to the accumulated value of your policy at a specific point in time. It consists of the "guaranteed cash value" and "non-guaranteed bonuses (or dividends) and interest (if any)". It mainly serves as the basis for cash value withdrawal, policy surrender or benefits payable upon policy maturity.

How Is Policy Cash Value Calculated?

For traditional participating insurance products, the total cash value is generally made up of the "guaranteed portion" plus the "non-guaranteed portion". Before purchasing a policy, you should carefully consider the proportion of guaranteed and non-guaranteed benefits in different products, as this directly affects the policy's potential growth and risks.
 
For example, if your primary goal is to plan for retirement income with a higher level of certainty, you may consider products with a higher guaranteed component. If your goal is long-term growth potential, you may consider products with a higher proportion of non-guaranteed benefits and greater potential for value growth. However, please note that non-guaranteed returns may be affected by investment market fluctuations, and the actual benefits payable may be higher or lower than expected.

What Is the Fulfilment Ratio? How to Interpret the Payment of Non-Guaranteed Benefits

The Fulfilment Ratio helps policyholders understand the insurer's past performance in delivering non-guaranteed benefits. It reflects the relationship between the aggregate actual accumulated non-guaranteed benefits against the illustrated aggregate amounts for all relevant policies at the point of sale.3
 
The basic calculation concept is: 
Fulfilment Ratio = Aggregate actual accumulated amount of non-guaranteed benefits ÷ Aggregate accumulated amount of non-guaranteed benefits illustrated at the point of sale 
 
However, please note that the fulfilment ratios are calculated on aggregate level among all relevant participating insurances including all premium payment terms of the product series and assumptions relating to premium payment, dividend/coupon payment options, withdrawal and policy loan, etc., are made, the fulfilment ratios shown in the table may not represent the situation of each individual participating insurance. 

What Does a 100% Fulfilment Ratio Represent?

When the Fulfilment Ratio is close to 100%, it generally means that the actual non-guaranteed benefits declared by the insurer are very close to the expected level illustrated at the point of sale. The figures have been rounded to the nearest whole percentage; therefore, a ratio displayed as 100% may be slightly higher or lower than 100%. If it is higher than 100%, it indicates that the actual non-guaranteed benefits declared in the past were higher than the expectations at the point of sale. Conversely, if it is lower than 100%, it indicates that the actual non-guaranteed benefits declared in the past were lower than the expectations at the point of sale. It is important to note that the Fulfilment Ratio reflects the comparison between past non-guaranteed benefit declarations and the expectations illustrated at the point of sale. It does not represent future dividend/ bonus declaration levels or the overall performance of an individual product.

Fulfilment Ratio for Annual Dividends, Reversionary Bonuses and Terminal Dividends

The dividends under participating insurances can mainly be categorised into several types, including Annual Dividends, Reversionary Bonuses and Terminal Dividends / Terminal Bonuses. As different types of bonuses have different payment mechanisms and characteristics, the key considerations when reviewing their Fulfilment Ratios may also vary. Please note that different types of bonuses may not be suitable for direct comparison across categories, as this may lead to inaccurate interpretations.
 
  • Annual Dividends

    Once declared, they are generally considered "vested / locked in", and customers may withdraw them at any time. The fulfillment ratios also reflect the aggregate actual accumulated annual dividends, and actual interests accumulated on dividend and guaranteed cash payment against the illustrated amounts at the point of sale for all relevant inforce policies in the reporting year.

  • Reversionary Bonuses

    They are declared based on the face amount. Once declared, the face value of the reversionary bonuses becomes part of the guaranteed benefits. However, the cash value of reversionary bonuses is not guaranteed and is generally reflected upon the death of the insured or surrender of the policy.

  • Terminal Dividends / Terminal Bonuses

    They are "unvested" and variable bonuses. Adjustments may be made more frequently than once a year. They are only payable upon policy termination (such as surrender, death or maturity), and the actual amount is determined at the time of payment.
 
You can learn more about the specific calculation and disclosure details of the Fulfilment Ratio for participating insurances.

Important Considerations When Interpreting the Fulfilment Ratio

  • Past performance does not represent future payouts: The Fulfilment Ratio only reflects the historical performance of the relevant product and is provided for reference purposes. It should not be regarded as an indicator or guarantee of the future declaration of dividends / bonuses of the relevant product. 
  • Differences in Fulfilment Ratios among individual policies: The officially disclosed Fulfilment Ratio is generally calculated on aggregate level among all relevant participating insurances including all premium payment terms of the product series and assumptions relating to premium payment, dividend/coupon payment options, withdrawal and policy loan, etc., are made, the fulfilment ratios shown in the table may not represent the situation of each individual participating insurance. It reflects the calculation results of the relevant product's policy portfolio rather than the actual results of each individual policy. If your individual policy has exercised a "premium holiday", withdrawn accumulated bonuses / cash value, or taken out a policy loan, the actual total return and cash value of your individual policy may differ from the officially disclosed Fulfilment Ratio or the original benefit illustration.

What Is the Total Cash Value Ratio (TCV Ratio)? How to Interpret Its Significance

Compared with the Fulfilment Ratio, which focuses mainly on non-guaranteed benefits, the Total Cash Value Ratio is a key indicator used to assess the overall performance of participating insurances. It compares the actual "total cash value" of a policy at the end of the policy year (including both guaranteed and non-guaranteed portions) with the amount stated in the benefit illustration (proposal) at the point of sale.4
 
The basic calculation concept is: 
Total Cash Value Ratio = Actual total cash value ÷ Total cash value illustrated in the benefit illustration at the point of sale 

Important Considerations When Interpreting the Total Cash Value Ratio

  • Specific assumptions: Similar to the Fulfilment Ratio, the calculation of this ratio is generally based on aggregate level among all relevant participating insurances including all premium payment terms of the product series and assumptions relating to premium payment, dividend/coupon payment options, withdrawal and policy loan, etc., are made, the Total Cash Value ratios shown in the table may not represent the situation of each individual participating insurance. 
  • Past performance does not represent future performance: Please note that the past Total Cash Value Ratio does not represent the future performance of a participating insurance.
  • A higher ratio does not necessarily mean a higher actual amount: There are two reasons: First, the denominator of the ratio is the expected amount shown in the benefit illustration at the point of sale. If the originally illustrated amount was relatively conservative, the actual amount may still be limited even if the ratio meets or exceeds 100%. Second, during the early years of a policy, the total cash value is generally lower than the total premiums paid. Therefore, even if the ratio exceeds 100%, this does not necessarily mean the policy has generated a positive return. Therefore, the ratio should be considered together with the actual amounts shown in the benefit illustration.
 
For more detailed data and calculation methods, you may refer to the Total Cash Value Ratio of participating insurances.

Fulfilment Ratio vs Total Cash Value Ratio: What Are the Differences Between These Two Indicators?

To help you better understand these two key indicators, the core differences between them are summarised below5:

Comparison Between Fulfilment Ratio and Total Cash Value Ratio

Comparison ItemFulfilment RatioTotal Cash Value Ratio (TCV Ratio)
Main PurposeTo understand the insurer's past performance in delivering non-guaranteed benefitsTo assess the past performance of the policy's overall cash value
Main FocusNon-guaranteed benefits only (such as Annual Dividends and Terminal Dividends)Total cash value (guaranteed cash value + non-guaranteed benefits)
Basic Calculation ConceptActual non-guaranteed benefits ÷ Non-guaranteed benefits illustrated in the benefit illustration at the point of saleActual total cash value ÷ Total cash value illustrated in the benefit illustration at the point of sale
Meaning of 100% as a ReferenceThe actual dividends declared are approximately the same as the level illustrated in the benefit illustration at the point of saleThe actual total cash value of the policy is approximately the same as the level illustrated in the benefit illustration at the point of sale
Key LimitationsDoes not reflect the overall value of the policy, as the guaranteed portion is not includedAs guaranteed cash value generally accounts for a higher proportion in the early years of a policy, changes in the non-guaranteed portion may have a relatively smaller impact on the overall ratio

How to Use These Two Ratios to Evaluate a Participating Insurance?

When evaluating a participating insurance, considering both ratios together can help you gain a more comprehensive understanding of the policy's past performance from two perspectives: "non-guaranteed benefit declarations" and "total cash value".
 
When conducting an assessment, it is important to avoid the limitations of "looking at only one ratio or one single year". The following analysis approaches are for reference only:
 
  • Observe Long-Term Performance Trends Across Different Policy Periods: Insurance is a long-term financial arrangement. A 100% Fulfilment Ratio during the first few years after policy inception may have limited reference value. Policyholders may review the historical data of the product or similar product series over a longer policy period to understand whether the insurer has made adjustments to bonus declarations in the past.  
  • Whether you are considering purchasing a new policy, or planning to surrender an existing policy, withdraw cash value or apply for a policy loan, please remember that these actions will directly affect your long-term asset accumulation.

What Factors Affect Your Policy Cash Value? Key Factors When Purchasing a Policy or Withdrawing Cash Value

The total cash value of a policy generally increases over the policy years. However, the non-guaranteed portion may be adjusted based on the actual dividends/bonuses declared by the insurer. It is affected by a combination of internal and external factors. Early surrender may result in financial loss and directly affect your future protection and long-term financial benefits.

Economic Environment and the Insurer's Investment Strategy

Changes in market interest rates, global stock market performance and bond yields, among other macroeconomic factors, may affect the actual performance of an insurer's investment portfolio. Fluctuations in investment returns may affect the non-guaranteed bonuses or dividends distributed to policyholders, which ultimately impact the total cash value of your policy.

Impact of Policy Loans and Automatic Premium Loans

If you choose to withdraw policy cash value or use your policy as collateral for borrowing, these actions may result in interest charges. For example, when you activate an "automatic premium loan" arrangement or apply for a policy loan, the borrowed principal will continue to accumulate interest on a compound basis.
 
Although these arrangements may provide flexibility for short-term cash flow needs or help maintain the policy when a premium payment is temporarily missed, any outstanding loan principal and accumulated interest will be deducted from your policy's total cash value. This may significantly reduce the final net surrender value you receive and negatively affect your long-term savings goals.
 
When the total amount of policy loan and accumulated interest reaches or exceeds the policy's specified cash value, the policy may automatically lapse, and the original protection coverage will terminate accordingly.

About Participating Insurances FAQs

The total cash value of a policy is the sum of the guaranteed cash value and non-guaranteed benefits. The Fulfilment Ratio specifically reflects the insurer's ability to deliver the "non-guaranteed benefits" (such as dividends), while the Total Cash Value Ratio compares the difference between the policy's actual overall value, including guaranteed cash value and non-guaranteed benefits, against the expected amount illustrated at the point of sale from a broader perspective.

The two are generally not the same. Depending on the product design and policy duration, the policy cash value is usually much lower than the total premiums paid during the early years of the policy. This is because the insurer needs to deduct operating expenses related to setting up the policy and the cost of providing life protection during the early policy years. The cash value may only have the opportunity to exceed the total premiums paid after the policy has accumulated over a longer period.

Dividends are considered "non-guaranteed benefits". The amount of dividends declared may be affected by various internal and external factors, including the actual investment performance of the insurer's relevant assets, claims experience and operating expenses. Therefore, the actual future amount declared may be lower or higher than the expected level stated in the benefit illustration (proposal) at the point of sale. Under extremely adverse economic or market conditions, the dividend payment for a particular year may be zero.

Yes, but there may be corresponding long-term impacts. Subject to the policy terms and conditions, policyholders may generally access funds through partial surrender or by applying for a policy loan. Partial surrender will permanently reduce the future life protection amount and long-term accumulation benefits, while policy loans will incur interest charges. Policyholders should note that if the outstanding loan principal and interest exceed the policy's total cash value, the policy may be at risk of lapsing.

This means that the actual non-guaranteed benefits declared by the insurer during that year (such as Annual Dividends or Terminal Dividends) are approximately the same as the expected amount illustrated in the benefit illustration (proposal) at the point of sale. As the ratio is rounded to the nearest percent, a displayed value of 100% may actually be slightly higher or lower. Please note that historical Fulfilment Ratios do not represent the future performance of participating insurances.

This means that the policy's "total cash value" for that year (i.e. guaranteed cash value plus all non-guaranteed benefits) is approximately the same as the expected level illustrated in the benefit illustration at the point of sale. As the ratio is rounded to the nearest percent, a displayed value of 100% may actually be slightly higher or lower than 100%. It should not be regarded as a guarantee of future performance.
The above information is for Hong Kong and/ or Macau only. The content contains general information only and shall not constitute, nor be construed as, any sales advice, investment or insurance advice, product recommendation, solicitation and/or offer of services. This information does not take into account any person's financial situation or needs, and should not be relied upon as the sole basis for making any financial, investment or insurance decision. Customer must complete the Financial Needs Analysis before applying for any insurance product. The product information on this website is for reference only and does not contain the full terms of the product. For details of the product features, terms and conditions, exclusions and key product risks, please refer to the relevant product brochure and policy contract of the relevant products. In case you want to read a sample of the policy contract before making an application, you can obtain a copy from AIA. Life insurance policies are long-term contracts of insurance. Should you surrender the policy early, you may receive an amount considerably less than the total amount of premiums paid. AIA does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the content and information contained herein. AIA shall not assume any liability in respect of the content, services and/or products referred to in this information.​
​
This article is owned by AIA, and may not be copied or reproduced without AIA's written consent. You may not copy or store this content on any other website or content platform. AIA reserves the absolute discretion to suspend or remove this article at any time without prior notice. In the event of any infringement and/or legal issues, AIA reserves the right to take appropriate legal action and seek compensation.​
​

1. Insurance Authority (IA), https://www.ia.org.hk/en/participating_policy/index.html  [Online source], [Accessed on 29 June 2026]
2. Investor and Financial Education Council (IFEC), https://www.ifec.org.hk/web/en/blog/2022/05/Two-considerations-before-purchasing-a-participating-policy.page, [Online source], [Accessed on 29 June 2026]
3. Insurance Authority (IA). https://www.ia.org.hk/en/fulfillment_ratio/index.html, [Online source], [Accessed on 29 June 2026]
4. ​​​ET Net, https://www.etnet.com.hk/www/tc/news/news-article.php?section=features&newsid=134929, [Online source], [Accessed on 29 June 2026]

You may also be interested in

Recommendation on product categories

Contact us now

error icon
Oops! Unable to perform this action. Please reload the page and try again.
info icon

*Required fields

  • error icon
  • error icon
  • error icon
  • error icon
alert icon
alert icon
alert icon
alert icon
alert icon
meet icon Contact Us
meet icon
Contact Us