ARTICLE
Participating Insurance: Fulfilment Ratio & Total Cash Value Ratio Guide
18-min read
Updated on 2026-9-25
Author: AIA Content Editorial Team
What Is a Participating Insurance? Understanding Its Basic Operating Principles
What Is the Difference Between Guaranteed Benefits and Non-Guaranteed Benefits?
Guaranteed Benefits:
Guaranteed benefits refer to the amounts stated in the policy terms and conditions that the insurance company is obligated to pay. Regardless of changes in market conditions, the insurer must pay the specified amount according to the policy terms.
Non-Guaranteed Benefits:
Non-guaranteed benefits refer to the portion of returns that may vary depending on different factors. The final amount payable may be affected by factors including the insurer's investment strategy and actual performance, claims experience, operating expenses and other relevant factors.
Key Differences Between Participating and Non-Participating Insurances
| Comparison Item | Participating Insurance | Non-Participating Insurance |
| Premium Level (for the same sum assured) | Generally relatively higher. | Generally relatively lower. |
| Return Potential | In general, a higher proportion of non-guaranteed benefits may indicate higher potential returns. However, the benefits received by policyholders may also be subject to greater fluctuations, and the uncertainty of non-guaranteed benefits may be relatively higher. | Generally provides fixed amounts stated in the policy, without additional returns. |
| Return Stability | May be affected by factors including the insurer's investment performance, claims experience and operating expenses, and therefore involves relatively higher fluctuation risks. | Relatively stable and not affected by market fluctuations. |
What Is Policy Cash Value?
How Is Policy Cash Value Calculated?
What Is the Fulfilment Ratio? How to Interpret the Payment of Non-Guaranteed Benefits
What Does a 100% Fulfilment Ratio Represent?
Fulfilment Ratio for Annual Dividends, Reversionary Bonuses and Terminal Dividends
Annual Dividends
Once declared, they are generally considered "vested / locked in", and customers may withdraw them at any time. The fulfillment ratios also reflect the aggregate actual accumulated annual dividends, and actual interests accumulated on dividend and guaranteed cash payment against the illustrated amounts at the point of sale for all relevant inforce policies in the reporting year.
Reversionary Bonuses
They are declared based on the face amount. Once declared, the face value of the reversionary bonuses becomes part of the guaranteed benefits. However, the cash value of reversionary bonuses is not guaranteed and is generally reflected upon the death of the insured or surrender of the policy.
Terminal Dividends / Terminal Bonuses
They are "unvested" and variable bonuses. Adjustments may be made more frequently than once a year. They are only payable upon policy termination (such as surrender, death or maturity), and the actual amount is determined at the time of payment.
Important Considerations When Interpreting the Fulfilment Ratio
- Past performance does not represent future payouts: The Fulfilment Ratio only reflects the historical performance of the relevant product and is provided for reference purposes. It should not be regarded as an indicator or guarantee of the future declaration of dividends / bonuses of the relevant product.
- Differences in Fulfilment Ratios among individual policies: The officially disclosed Fulfilment Ratio is generally calculated on aggregate level among all relevant participating insurances including all premium payment terms of the product series and assumptions relating to premium payment, dividend/coupon payment options, withdrawal and policy loan, etc., are made, the fulfilment ratios shown in the table may not represent the situation of each individual participating insurance. It reflects the calculation results of the relevant product's policy portfolio rather than the actual results of each individual policy. If your individual policy has exercised a "premium holiday", withdrawn accumulated bonuses / cash value, or taken out a policy loan, the actual total return and cash value of your individual policy may differ from the officially disclosed Fulfilment Ratio or the original benefit illustration.
What Is the Total Cash Value Ratio (TCV Ratio)? How to Interpret Its Significance
Important Considerations When Interpreting the Total Cash Value Ratio
- Specific assumptions: Similar to the Fulfilment Ratio, the calculation of this ratio is generally based on aggregate level among all relevant participating insurances including all premium payment terms of the product series and assumptions relating to premium payment, dividend/coupon payment options, withdrawal and policy loan, etc., are made, the Total Cash Value ratios shown in the table may not represent the situation of each individual participating insurance.
- Past performance does not represent future performance: Please note that the past Total Cash Value Ratio does not represent the future performance of a participating insurance.
- A higher ratio does not necessarily mean a higher actual amount: There are two reasons: First, the denominator of the ratio is the expected amount shown in the benefit illustration at the point of sale. If the originally illustrated amount was relatively conservative, the actual amount may still be limited even if the ratio meets or exceeds 100%. Second, during the early years of a policy, the total cash value is generally lower than the total premiums paid. Therefore, even if the ratio exceeds 100%, this does not necessarily mean the policy has generated a positive return. Therefore, the ratio should be considered together with the actual amounts shown in the benefit illustration.
Fulfilment Ratio vs Total Cash Value Ratio: What Are the Differences Between These Two Indicators?
Comparison Between Fulfilment Ratio and Total Cash Value Ratio
| Comparison Item | Fulfilment Ratio | Total Cash Value Ratio (TCV Ratio) |
| Main Purpose | To understand the insurer's past performance in delivering non-guaranteed benefits | To assess the past performance of the policy's overall cash value |
| Main Focus | Non-guaranteed benefits only (such as Annual Dividends and Terminal Dividends) | Total cash value (guaranteed cash value + non-guaranteed benefits) |
| Basic Calculation Concept | Actual non-guaranteed benefits ÷ Non-guaranteed benefits illustrated in the benefit illustration at the point of sale | Actual total cash value ÷ Total cash value illustrated in the benefit illustration at the point of sale |
| Meaning of 100% as a Reference | The actual dividends declared are approximately the same as the level illustrated in the benefit illustration at the point of sale | The actual total cash value of the policy is approximately the same as the level illustrated in the benefit illustration at the point of sale |
| Key Limitations | Does not reflect the overall value of the policy, as the guaranteed portion is not included | As guaranteed cash value generally accounts for a higher proportion in the early years of a policy, changes in the non-guaranteed portion may have a relatively smaller impact on the overall ratio |
How to Use These Two Ratios to Evaluate a Participating Insurance?
- Observe Long-Term Performance Trends Across Different Policy Periods: Insurance is a long-term financial arrangement. A 100% Fulfilment Ratio during the first few years after policy inception may have limited reference value. Policyholders may review the historical data of the product or similar product series over a longer policy period to understand whether the insurer has made adjustments to bonus declarations in the past.
- Whether you are considering purchasing a new policy, or planning to surrender an existing policy, withdraw cash value or apply for a policy loan, please remember that these actions will directly affect your long-term asset accumulation.
What Factors Affect Your Policy Cash Value? Key Factors When Purchasing a Policy or Withdrawing Cash Value
Economic Environment and the Insurer's Investment Strategy
Impact of Policy Loans and Automatic Premium Loans
About Participating Insurances FAQs
This article is owned by AIA, and may not be copied or reproduced without AIA's written consent. You may not copy or store this content on any other website or content platform. AIA reserves the absolute discretion to suspend or remove this article at any time without prior notice. In the event of any infringement and/or legal issues, AIA reserves the right to take appropriate legal action and seek compensation.